Showing posts with label Mystery. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Mystery. Show all posts

The Disappearance of Agatha


I've been on a bit of an Agatha Christie binge lately, helped along by Masterpiece Theater and their fabulous renderings of some of the best Hercules Poirot and Miss Marple mysteries. Although she wrote more than just the Poirot and Marple series - did you know she wrote romance novels under the pseudonym Mary Westmacott? - Christie will always be known as the Queen of Mystery. She's also the most-read novelist of all time. We know so much about her as a novelist, but little is ever discussed about her personal life.



Of course this wasn't always the case. In 1926, the Queen of Mystery made headlines around the world when she herself disappeared. It was a Friday, December 23, when Agatha Christie kissed her daughter goodnight and left her home in Berkshire around 9:45 pm and drove away without explanation. Her abandoned car was later found near Guildford but without a trace of the author to be found. No clues. No ransom note. No sign of foul play. 



Christie was enjoying the soaring heights of success. The Murder of Roger Ackroyd was her newest novel and was enjoying exceptional sales. As the days passed with no sign of the author, the country began to fear the worst. Police mobilized 15,000 volunteers to search the local area, including a local lake called the Silent Pool which Christie had used in one of her novels for a character's death. Suspicion also turned toward Christie's dashing WWI Airman husband, Colonel Archibald Christie (police even tapped his phone); suspicions perhaps not too unfounded, as it turned out.



For eleven days England feared the worst. Then, inexplicably, Christie was discovered safe and sound at a spa in Harrogate, signed in under the name of Theresa Neele (if you're keeping track of clues, this is one is important). If you're wondering what the hell? you're not alone. So was everyone else. Word on the street was that Christie was suffering from temporary amnesia, but really, no one was really talking, especially Christie herself.

What we do know:

1. The good Colonel Archibald was indeed playing hokey-pokey on the side. He had found himself a mistress by the name of Nancy Neele (ahem, note the name) and was, in fact, spending the very weekend of the disappearance cooped up in a love-nest with his mistress. Prior to Christie's disappearance that night, the Colonel had informed Agatha that despite twelve years of marriage and a child together, he had fallen in love with the good Ms. Neele and wanted a divorce.

2. Earlier in the year, Christie's mother, with whom she was quite close, had passed away. It had fallen to Christie to deal with the post-death arrangements as well as the closing up of her childhood home. Christie's husband, the Colonel, being otherwise occupied (see #1).

3. Christie wrote several confusing (or misdirecting?) letters just prior to her disappearance. One was to the local police constable stating that she feared for her life. Another was to her brother-in-law (Colonel Archie's brother) telling him she would be leaving on a spa vacation shortly. Indeed she would.

4. While the country was expecting the worst and all resources mobilized, Agatha placed an advertisement in the London Times stating that Mrs Theresea Neele was looking to get in touch with relatives and they could find her at the spa in Harrogate. It wasn't until her fellow guests at the spa began note the similarities between "Theresa Neele" and the missing Agatha Christie that the whole thing blew up. Colonel Christie drove down to the spa, scooped her up and that was that.

5. England was, needless to say, absolutely furious. Most people believed that the entire thing either was a staged publicity stunt set up by Christie's publisher to up the sales of her book, despite doctor's statements to the contrary or a personal vendetta by Christie herself to punish her wayward husband. The wasted resources and - most likely - the disappointment over a possible national tragedy turning into a simple spa visit inspired righteous indignation as only the English can produce. 

6. The official word from the Christie camp seemed to claim temporary amnesia brought on by stress, although incident was swept under the rug as quickly as possible and never officially spoken of by the author herself ever again. She and the Colonel never lived together again and their divorce became final in 1928. How she put her life back together is another story altogether.

The disappearance of Agatha Christie remained one of the most gossiped-about events of the early part of the 20th century. But for me, it is only a glimpse into what must have been one of the most excruciatingly painful periods of Christie's life. The death of her mother; a husband who was obviously crappy even before he requested a divorce. This was 1926 when the Colonel would have every right, despite his philandering and downright crappiness, to expect to obtain full custody of their daughter. While her writing may have been a success, her personal life was completely disintegrating. 

So did Christie suffer from temporary amnesia? Frankly, it's none of my business. I'm simply thankful that she made it through that period of her life and went on to find stability, happiness, and a typewriter. Because if she hadn't, the world would be a lesser place.

Oh, and one last thing. In 2013, a very valuable silver cigarette case came up for auction in London. It was fondly inscribed to a certain man from Mr. and Mrs. Christie in 1926. The man in question happened to be the person who blew the whistle on Agatha at Harrogate Spa all those years ago, alerting authorities as to where their missing author really was. Make of that what you will, super-sleuths.

Welcome to the Detection Club

I recently finished reading the new William Morrow edition of Agatha Christie's classic mystery novel After the Funeral. It goes without saying that there really cannot be too many editions of the Queen of Mystery's books and this particular Poirot whodunit remains one of her more satisfying efforts. After turning the last page, once again failing to name the culprit before the big reveal (yes, I used a detective's log and no it didn't work), I flipped back to the introduction I had skipped over in my haste to begin the story. (I have a horrible habit of skipping introductions. I don't want to hear what someone else thinks of a book before I even begin reading reading it. Spoilers lurk everywhere in introductions. It is a minefield to be avoided at all costs.)



This particular introduction was written by Sophie Hannah, the author who was chosen to pen the upcoming "Agatha Christie Mystery" The Monogram Murders. (If you harbor doubts about anyone else - regardless of talent - writing as Agatha Christie allow me to assure you that you're not alone. But that is a discussion for another day.) In her introduction Hannah muses that the kind of mysteries Christie wrote, "the ones with the high-concept, seemingly-impossible-yet-possible solutions, the ones that take your breath away," would not curry favor with contemporary readers whose "expectations of novels have changed." She notes that during Christie's time, readers simply expected an exciting story, while today's readers expect more realism. In some sub-genres, of course, this is true. She never explicitly says so (and I wondered if she knew it herself), but she is simply describing what is known as the different Schools of Mystery.

Agatha Christie belonged to what is known as The Golden Age of the British Detective Novel which flourished between the 1920s and the 1930s (also called Puzzle-Plots). Cleverness was the name of the game and outwitting the reader was the goal. Grisly violence, social or political commentary, and descriptive sex was all off limits because it was untidy and couldn't be resolved with a return to nice, neat British social order by the end. Our cousins across the pond do love things nice and tidy...little wonder I harbor such an affinity for them. 

Agatha Christie
And who can blame the public for making these novels bestsellers? The 1920s saw Europe in tatters. World War I had just ended and everyone was still questioning the death, the carnage. For what? Order - not just social order - had been destroyed. The Lost Generation was groping it's way through the arts.  Fascism was rising across the Continent. The average reader lacked an anchor...stability. The British detective novels were, if not quite solvable for the average reader, predictable in format. They provided a safe feeling that order would be restored by the end of the novel.

In 1928 a group of authors gathered together to form a club (a club which is still, by the way, still in existence today). They called it the Detection Club. The first President was C.K. Chesterton. Founding members: Agatha Christie, Dorothy L. Sayers, Anthony Berkeley, Gladys Mitchell, Miles Burton/John Rhode, Father Ronald Knox, and Freeman Wills Croft. Members of the club agreed to rigidly adhere to the following ten rules as established by Knox:

  1. The criminal must be someone mentioned in the early part of the story, but must not be anyone whose thoughts the reader has been allowed to follow.
  2. All supernatural or preternatural agencies are ruled out as a matter of course.
  3. Not more than one secret room or passage is allowable.
  4. No hitherto undiscovered poisons may be used, nor any appliance which will need a long scientific explanation at the end.
  5. No Chinaman may figure in the story.
  6. No accident must ever help the detective, nor must he ever have an unaccountable intuition which proves to be right.
  7. The detective must not himself commit the crime.
  8. The detective must not light on any clues which are not instantly produced for the inspection of the reader.
  9. The stupid friend of the detective, the Watson, must not conceal any thoughts which pass through his mind; his intelligence must be slightly, but very slightly, below that of the average reader.
  10. Twin brothers, and doubles generally, must not appear unless we have been duly prepared for them.

1932 Detection Club Dinner
If the rules and format of a British Detective Novel from the Golden Age sound vaguely familiar to modern day readers, it might be because you still see their offspring in what we now refer to as cosy mysteries. I find it fascinating that the name of the sub-genre reflects the comfort that the original genre produced in it's audiences. I don't believe that to be coincidence.

The Puzzle-Plots that Agatha Christie wrote were only one of many Schools of Mystery that have made an appearance since Edgar Allan Poe first ushered in what would become an irresistible genre of reading. From hard-boiled detective fiction to locked-room mysteries; from police procedurals to psychological thrillers, the mystery genre has a variety of schools that are all worthy of study. I'm not entirely certain that they completely evolved from reader demands, but rather were simply a reflection of the times. While Sophie Hannah contends that modern day readers find Christie's plots not "plausible" enough to find commercial success, I would argue that the fact that William Morrow is publishing brand-new editions of Christie's novels refutes that argument entirely. 


ELIZABETH IS MISSING



Empathy is one of the most powerful traits human beings possess. When it is present, we see great things accomplished to alleviate the suffering of others. When it is absent, the greed and lust for power lead to some the greatest atrocities the world has ever witnessed. Yet for all of it's vast importance, the subject of empathy is often overlooked in our society. There are no formal classes to teach empathy, no popular parenting books to guide it's induction into our youth. One either learns it or they don't. 

One of the most important ways we do learn empathy is through reading books. A skillfully written novel can place the reader in another person's shoes in the span of a mere paragraph and hold them there for a lifetime. One suspects that author Emma Healey took this responsibility quite seriously when she set out to write her debut novel Elizabeth is Missing, a mystery most notable for it's astounding narration: a elderly woman beset with dementia.

At eighty-two, Maud doesn't have many friends left and her best friend, Elizabeth, has gone missing. Maud is determined to find her. Maud's heartbreaking dementia -- which the reader suffers right along with her with every turn of the page - makes finding Elizabeth a daunting task. Maud knows good and well that her memory is slipping - she writes herself dozens of notes to rectify the problem, then finds she can't remember when or why she wrote the notes - but seems unaware the severity of her condition.


One thing Maud does remember: Elizabeth is missing. And like many dementia patients, Maud frequently slips into the past, confusing it with the present. This presents a dual story line that takes us back to 1946 when Maud's sister went missing just after WWII had drawn to a close and England was trying to pick up the pieces. Maud, only a young teenager at the time, idolized her beautiful and sophisticated older sister Sukey, a newly married bride who suddenly disappears without a trace amid the chaos of a country traumatized by war. Presumed dead by foul play with no body ever recovered or suspect ever arrested for the crime, Sukey's unresolved disappearance and the trauma it inflicted upon Maud is woven throughout the narrative and underscores why it is so imperative that Maud find the missing Elizabeth. If she could just remember....("I quickly retrieve my pen. Elizabeth all right says son, I write. Said fuck on phone, I add, though I'm not sure why it's significant.")

As we slip back and forth between Maud's past and present, it presents a horrifying picture of what it is like to suffer from this disease. Because as the book progresses, so too does Maud's dementia. She finds herself spending more and more time in the past and increasingly unable to differentiate between the years. And she isn't the only person suffering: her daughter Helen, as primary caregiver, is frequently taxed to the limit as she is required to do everything from extricating her mother from the police station in the middle of the night to finally being forced to admit that Maud can no longer live independently. Bringing her mother into her own home only serves in increase the Maud's confusion which frequently erupts as frustration and anger. As is often the case, if Maud's degenerative condition wasn't so tragic, there would be moments of humor...


There is, of course, no cure for dementia and as such, Elizabeth is Missing can have no happy ending. That, however, will not serve as an adequate excuse for skipping this novel. Although mysteries both past and present do get resolved by the end of the story, don't read it for the whodunit properties or a resolution filled with social justice. Read it because it is a well-written, well-structured novel with a unique voice. Read it because although it is frightening and sad to see the world through the eyes of a dementia patient, it creates empathy. Read it because it - hopefully - makes you a better person.

********************
Title: Elizabeth is Missing
Author: Emma Healey
Publisher: Harper
Date: June 10, 2014
Pages: 320
Source:  advance copy courtesy of publisher

Mayhem


Confession: I'm misleading you already. See that gorgeous cover up there? It's enough to make a cover whore like myself stop, stare, and covet. But I have good news and bad news. The good news is that the story is completely worthy of this gorgeous cover (I'll get to that part in a few moments). The bad news is that this the UK cover. We heathens here in the Colonies were not deemed worthy of such gorgeousness and instead were graced with this:



Is it any wonder we rebelled against King George III? I mean, really. If taxation without representation and unattractive book covers were to be our lot in life, what did England expect?

Alright, assuming it is what's inside the cover that truly counts (and yes, it is), Mayhem is a deliciously creepy foray into the dark world of Victorian London where the city is frozen with fear as Jack the Ripper terrorizes Whitechapel. But London in the late 1880s was also victim to another vicious killer now largely lost to history. Dubbed the Thames Torso Murders, dismembered female victims began showing up in the Thames river throughout London beginning in May 1887. An astute police surgeon, one Dr. Thomas Bond, was the first to recognize that these corpses showing up in the Thames had been dismembered by someone with surgical skill and training.



Author Sarah Pinborough has unearthed this lost and disturbing tidbit of history and turned it into a compelling fictional account of Dr. Bond's investigation into the Thames Torso Murders. 

Admittedly, this was an interesting journey for me. I had never read any of Pinborough's work before and was hesitant to pick up what I - erroneously, as it turns out - thought to be yet another Jack the Ripper novel. Instead of boredom, I found myself drawn in from the very first page into the thick, damp fog permeating the Gothic atmosphere of the novel as the squalid conditions of the less fortunate side of Victorian London's population immediately came alive. 

Jack the Ripper, thankfully, takes the backstage to our protagonist - Dr. Thomas Bond himself - as he struggles with the limitations of the times to find the monster who is dismembering victims and dumping them in the Thames. Yet in Pinborogh's skillful hands, even the murders themselves are secondary to the character of Dr. Bond. Possessed of a brilliant mind, his empathy with victims of London's poor and disenfranchised is not an asset but a demon that haunts his every moment. How the ugliness of his world changes him and his attempts to escape the torture it inflicts upon him is a vital part of the story. Dr. Bond is a necessarily flawed character and his deterioration mirrors the investigation he doggedly pursues.

And now, for the twist. Just to throw me off balance, Pinborogh tosses in a touch - just a teensy touch, mind you - of the supernatural. Think of it as a sprinkle of garnish on a well-made dish. Too much would ruin the meal. Too little and the chef shouldn't have bothered. But the perfect small amount? Ahhhhh. Nicely done.

I've heard through the grapevine that Mayhem is to be the first in a series to feature Dr. Bond. If so, Pinborough can count me in for the ride. Nicely done. Hits bookstores tomorrow. 


Title: Mayhem
Author: Sarah Pinborough
Publisher: Jo Fletcher Books
Date:  January 14, 2012
Source:  Publisher

The Longmire Mysteries

On a recent vacation to visit family in a remote region of Oregon (and I do mean remote: mail is delivered three days a week, via boat), I found myself at said family's mercy when it came to entertainment.  The good news was that there was plenty of time to kick back and read throughout the day as the family made general idiots of themselves water-skiing across the lake for hours on end.  The bad news was that I found myself at their mercy at the end of the day when the television came on.

Determined to be a good sport, this non-television-watching gal tucked up on the couch determined to feign interest in whatever insipid popular, brainless show they were addicted to.  See what a good sport I am?  So you can imagine my surprise when they tuned into a series (which of course I had never heard of) that was, well, actually good. You may have heard of it. A little modern-day, western mystery series over on A&E going by the name of Longmire.  And best of all?  My beady little eyes honed in on the opening credits which read:  "Based on the books by Craig Johnson".  Well, well, well. What have we here?



Now the episodes I watched there were pretty darned good.  But you can be damned sure I got up the next morning and downloaded the first of Craig Johnson's books, The Cold Dish.  And read it in one afternoon. It was that good. Yes, far, far better than the television version.



If you're not familiar with the premise, let me fill you in. Walt Longmire is the sheriff in a sparsely populated county in Wyoming. Okay, all counties in Wyoming are sparsely populated, but this one particularly so.  He's been doing this a while, so he's a little jaded. And Wyoming towns are really small town. If you've ever been there, you know what I'm talking about. I myself had the particular pleasure (not sure if that's sarcasm or not) of flying freight throughout Wyoming in my younger years so I understood immediately the tone of the books and perhaps experienced some displaced nostalgia. But I digress.

Walt has a deputy, Vic, from Philadelphia.  She's good at what she does and brings a much-needed dose of the big city to the place, though she has a mouth on her like a sailor on shore-leave. Walt's best-friend, Henry Standing Bear, is a Cheyenne who runs the only bar in town. Everyone has a hysterically dry sense of humor although it's clear they aren't aware of that.
"Slugs basically convert shotguns into oversize rifles with enough power to crack automobile engine blocks."
"Why would somebody want to shoot somebody with something like that?"
"Emphasis."
So while I laughed myself silly throughout, the mysteries themselves are actually quite serious. As I mentioned, Wyoming isn't exactly populous so when a murder occurs it is a momentous occasion. Johnson creates crimes riddled with both legal and moral quagmires that make this much more than a typical whodunit mystery.

Still, there is the laughter.
"You want to take a ride?"
"I'm saddled and, if you're waitin' for me, yer backin' up."
It was like working with Louis L'Amour.
All in all, I'm thoroughly grateful there are ten books in the series. And while I do recommend picking up the books, I cannot in all good conscious, recommend Wyoming. Especially Rock Springs. Ugh. (There, see?  I just lost another reader.)



Title:  The Cold Dish
Author:  Craig Johnson
Publisher:  Penguin (Reprint Edition)
Date:  2012
Pages:  400
Source:  Bought it.  Lock, stock and proverbial barrel.

Rating:  Five Stars

It's Thanksgiving!

Those of us who generally work on holidays tend to lose track of them.  So you can imagine our surprise this morning when we discovered that today is actually Thanksgiving.  (Whoops)  Of course the first thing that came to mind is, "Where's our damned turkey?", but once we reconciled ourselves to the fact that Thanksgiving dinners aren't traditionally served up in airports, we began to think about the real meaning of the holiday and realized there is something we are very grateful for indeed this year:

We are grateful for Alan Bradley.  If you haven't heard of him, allow us to fill you in.  Alan Bradley is a retired director of television engineering who lives in Canada.  When he retired in 1994, he decided to write a novel.  He called his book The Sweetness at the Bottom of the Pie and in it he introduced to the world one of the most creative, witty, precocious protagonists ever to grace the pages of a novel, Miss Flavia de Luce.

Flavia is the smartest eleven year old you will ever meet.  The youngest daughter of widower Colonel de Luce, Flavia lives an entirely dysfunctional life in the sleepy English hamlet of Bishop's Lacy in her family's rambling historical estate.  Left to her own devices, she spends her days teaching herself chemistry (her one passion in this world) and torturing her elder sisters, the self-absorbed Ophelia ("Feely") and the bibliophile Daphne.  Oh, and she solves murders, too.



Just because an eleven year old is the main character is Bradley's series of sharp mysteries, don't mistake these books for Young Adult.  They most certainly are not.  The Flavia de Luce series is most assuredly written for adults - adults that appreciate whimsy and wit.

Although he was a very great musician, and a wizard composer of symphonies, Beethoven was quite often a dismal failure when it came to ending them.  The Fifth was a perfect case in point.

Dum. . . dum. . . dum-dum-dum, it would go, and you would think it was over.

But no--

Dum, dah, dum, dah, dum, dah, dum, da, dum, dah, dum---DAH dum.

You'd go to get up and stretch, sighing with satifaction at the great work you'd just listened to, and suddenly:

DAH dum.  DAH. dum.  DAH dum.  And so forth.  DAH dum.

It was like a bit of flypaper stuck to your finger that you couldn't shake off.  The bloody thing clung to life like a limpet.

(from The Weed that Strings the Hangman's Bag)

Flavia's droll wit and astute powers of observation are without peer in the mystery world.   If you haven't read the series (there are currently four books), don't get left behind.  Track down a copy of the first book in the series, The Sweetness at the Bottom of the Pie, and be thankful for authors that can write like this.  A Reader's Respite is.  (Oh, and we're also thankful for the Dunkin' Donuts in O'Hare Airport that is open and serving coffee to the rest of us working this holiday!)


A Proper Halloween

A Reader's Respite originally had planned a whole slew of spooky Halloween reviews throughout the month of October.  Due to, ahem, some technical difficulties (oddly enough, not with Blogger this time but within our own short-circuiting brain) it simply did not happen this year.  The best laid plans.....

But in the never-say-die spirit (double entendre there....look at us, back in the game!) we do want to share our favorite Halloween read this year.



When we first read about this almost-forgotten mystery first published in 1945 over at Kittling: Books, we ordered it immediately.  Really, what's more fun than a proper British mystery, ala Agatha Christie?

And for those of you who love a little mystery with their mystery, you'll be intrigued to know that author Maureen Sarsfield is a bit of a mystery herself.  After publishing two successful mystery novels, she simply vanished.  No one knows what became of her, whether it was a pen name, or even if she simply passed away.  Intriguing, no?

Murder at Shots Hall is a hoot of a romp through the English countryside where a local heart-breaker named Flik is accused of a series of murders occurring around town.

Despite Flik's annoying habit of making every man she meets fall madly in love with her (and yes, it did indeed become annoying after a while), the mystery is a sound one and like most British mysteries, it's the eccentric cast of secondary characters that make this short novel  (191 pages) worth reading.  From the Detective Sergeant Arnoldson who is out to convict Flik of anything he can hang his hat on, to Camilla Pain-Wentworth who, it is said, would "flirt with a broomstick if it wore trousers," there is a fun array of possible suspects to choose from when local folks start turning up dead.

Our favorite?  Sergeant Congreve, local law enforcement with a knack for seeing through the bullshit and making us laugh out loud.  His initial written report after the first murder:

"Report from Sgt. Congreve.  All except the following, in and around Shotshall, had alibis for the night of December 1st between the hours of 19:45 and 21:00:  Capt. Belairs, who said he was in his house reading.  Miss Chattock, of Shots Hall, who said she was in her house doing nothing.  Mrs. Ashely who said what she was doing but it is not proven.  Mrs. Vale who said she was asleep in front of her fire which had gone out.  Harry Fewsey the butcher who was cutting up meat in his shop and said anyone ought to have been able to hear him doing it only no one did.  Winnie Marsh who said she had one round the corner, which one she would not say, to meet a boyfriend she won't say either as it is not her regular one Bill Ellison, and she said not to tell about it as Bill Ellison would be mad."

What's not to love?  Even if you figure out whodunnit, the fun is in the getting there.

Happy Halloween!

RIP: Shutter Island

Title:  Shutter Island
Author:  Dennis Lehane
Publisher:  Harper Collins
Format: Unabridged Audiobook
Narrator:  Tom Stechschulte
ASIN:  B001NJ5XM2
Length:  9 hours, 38 minutes
Source:  Personal Copy
Grade: A






A Reader's Respite came close to missing this gem of a thriller.  Why?  Because some idiots out in Hollywood decided that Dennis Lehane's novels make good movies (well, based on Mystic River, they're probably right).  But while we didn't see Shutter Island on film, we did see the movie trailer, which presented the tale as a scary, scary horror-type movie.  A Reader's Respite was just turned off, Leo or no.

Is it just us, or does he still look like he's 12 years old?  (a 12 year old with a beard, that is)

So now it's time to set the record straight:  Shutter Island is NOT a horror story in any way, shape or form.  It is, however, a fabulously executed thriller that gets the old heart pumping.

The time?  The 1950s.

The place?  Shutter Island, a small government island in Boston Harbor.

The set-up?  Two U.S. Marshals are sent out to Shutter Island - where the government runs an asylum for the criminally insane - to investigate the disappearance of a female patient.  Not all is what it seems to be at Shutter Island and things go very much bump-in-the-night as the two marshals get caught up in a creepy mystery and a hurricane descends upon the Eastern Seaboard, effectively cutting off Shutter Island from the rest of the world.

Sandy recommended this on audio and she was spot on, as usual.  Our narrator is pitch-perfect and Dennis Lehane hits another one out of the ballpark.

Highly, highly recommended!


A Reader's Respite Creep-O-Meter:


Tana French just keeps getting better....


Title: Faithful Place
Author:  Tana French
Genre:  Suspense
ISBN:  978-0670021871
416 pages
Source:  Amazon Purchase
Grade:  A+


If A Reader's Respite had to name one author who just keeps improving and improving with each book, it would have to be Tana French.  And her newest release, Faithful Place, just proves our claim.  Once again, French takes us to Dublin where undercover cop Frank Mackey finds himself drawn back to his childhood neighborhood (and slightly insane family) to solve the murder of his first teenage love, whose body has just been discovered after she went missing twenty-two years prior.

And once again, French shows the reader that it isn't the mystery that's important....it's the psychological characterizations that make the tale.  Without a doubt, this is her best effort to date.


Her first novel, In the Woods, debuted in 2007 to critical acclaim (it won an Edgar Award that year).  Reviews of the novel from readers weren't as impressive as the critics, though.  Many readers didn't care for the ambiguous ending of the suspense novel about the Dublin Murder Squad, although most would agree that French's writing was almost magical.  Her lyrical writing, sharp and witty dialog, and intense characterizations put the reader smack in the middle of Dublin, making her one of those rare authors who could transport a reader out of time and place.

In 2008 French followed up with The Likeness, another novel about the Dublin Murder Squad, this time focusing on a secondary character who appeared in the first novel.  This time, French nailed it.  A stunning ending wrapped up a novel with near-perfect psychological insight and again, she places the reader right in the time and place she created.

Unlike The Likeness, which almost required the reader to have been familiar with her first novel, Faithful Place requires no such previous reading.  Although Frank Mackey does appear as a secondary character in The Likeness, no other information from that book is needed to get full enjoyment out of Faithful Place.  Mackey is masterfully drawn...just the right amount of cynacism one needs from an undercover agent, mixed with irreverance for the rules and a good dose smart-ass.

A Reader's Respite might be just a little bit in love with Frank Mackey.

The mystery of who killed Rosie is not paramount, so don't expect a big twist at the end.  What's important here are the psychological foundations of relationships....relationships with family, with lovers, and with our children.  French is at the top of her game here.

If you haven't read a Tana French novel yet, it comes with our highest recommendation.  Don't feel like you have to go back to the beginning, though.....just pick up a copy of Faithful Place and savor it. 

Then come back here and join the Frank Mackey fan club.

Finding Authors in Books.....



A Reader's Respite has recently become intrigued by the practice of famous authors appearing in recent works of fiction as protagonists.  We're not entirely sure why this practice is so appealing to us, but we've found ourselves drawn to these books.

By and large, most of these novels are of the mystery genre.  Take author Michael Atkinson's new mystery novel, Hemingway Deadlights.


A Reader's Respite was fascinated by the concept of author Ernest Hemingway as a drunk, Pulitzer-Prize winning author between books who becomes involved in a gritty murder mystery in Key West.  That the entire plot was glaringly improbable did not, to our amazement, disrupt our enjoyment of watching the grumpy, grizzled Hemingway take on the Mafia in Havana during it's heyday in order to solve the mystery of a friend's death.  In fact, we found ourselves amused at Hemingway's antics (and drinking habits) throughout the mystery.  Atkinson plans an entire series here.



We've previously mentioned our encounter with author Stephanie Barron's mystery series starring none other than Jane Austen.  This series of cozy mysteries finds Jane solving all sorts of local crimes and Barron does a respectable job in rendering the mysteries as Jane herself might have related them (complete with psudeo-scholarly footnotes smattered throughout).




None other than the famous playwright Oscar Wilde stars in Gyles Brandreth's new Victorian mystery series.  Delivered using Wilde's scathing wit, the rascally author has appeared in three of these novels thus far and his complicated private life is thoroughly incorporated into the pages, making for both a compelling plot and a fascinating insight into Wilde's private life.




Matthew Pearl struck publishing gold when his novel The Dante Club hit the shelves a few years back.  The novel features American poet Henry Wadsworth Longfellow (and a few other famous Americans) solving a crime and finding a serial killer in 1865 Boston.  Like the previous novels mentioned, Pearl adapts the literary style of the author he features, a indispensable part of the novel's success.  Pearl has found success in this sub-genre (once called historical literary thriller by the Washington Post), also publishing The Last Dickens and The Poe Shadow.  We're assuming you can figure out who the subjects are by the title alone.



Another successful novel, short listed for the Booker Prize back in 2005, was the novel featuring Sir Arthur Conan Doyle (of Sherlock Holmes fame) by Julian Barnes.  Doyle is found here investigating the conviction of  local lawyer under fishy circumstances.  Less "cozy" than the other mysteries featured here, Arthur and George is provocative character study.  Author Barnes has also written about other literary figures.  His novel Flaubert's Parrot is a fictional expose of the author, although Gustave Flaubert is not a character, per se, in the novel but rather the subject.


Not a mystery, but a novel featuring William Shakespeare as the protagonist, Nothing Like the Sun imagines Shakespeare's early life and loves in this story that preceded the more famous Shakespeare in Love. Shakespeare's literary style is applied throughout and you'll find his sonnets liberally scattered throughout the novel, providing some insight into the playwright's famous words.


More recently, Kelly O'Connor McNees wrote a novelization of author Louisa May Alcott's mysterious love life in 1855 New Hampshire.  A lighter, more romantic novel, the story imagines Alcott's love of a local man...all the more intriguing because Alcott mysteriously never married.  The Lost Summer of Louisa May Alcott undeniably stirs interest in Alcott's works the most famous being Little Women.




There are numerous other novels featuring well known authors as protagonists, but we'll leave you with one last notable book: Little Fugue.  Author Robert Anderson doesn't place poet Sylvia Plath as a protagonist, per se, but this fictional work does feature Plath's poet husband Ted Hughes as he and others deal with the traumatic aftermath of Plath's suicide.  Critically well-received, Anderson tends to place Plath on a very high pedestal indeed.  But regardless of this (in our considered opinion) error, the novel offers fascinating insight into one of America's most tortured literary figures.

Know of any other novels featuring famous authors?  Tell us about them!

A Pair O' Irish Thrillers

Have you read Irish author Tana French's books yet? If you haven't, A Reader's Respite is telling you that you really should.




Her first novel, entitled In the Woods, has actually been out and about for a few years now and was the recipient of the 2007 Edgar Award for Best First Novel. And what a fabulous novel it was:  French introduced us to Dublin detectives Rob Ryan and Cassie Maddox, unlikely (yet most likable) partners who must dig deep into the past to solve a creepy modern day murder.

French's talent lies in characterization and dialog.  Told from Detective Rob Ryan's point of view, Rob and Cassie leap off the pages with ease and it feels as if their world has come to life.  Sophisticated dialog and tantalizing glimpses into each detective's past make it seem as if French has been doing this her whole life, rather than debuting with this novel.  She writes with a fluidity that indicates maturity far beyond her years.

As the murder mystery deepens it becomes apparent that Detective Ryan's past is intricately entwined with the current case and the stakes are raised until the reader simply can not put the book down.  Truly, we didn't shower for two days in order to finish this book.



Now here's where it gets interesting because A Reader's Respite is just going to flat out tell you the truth of the matter:

The ending just plain sucks.

Really, it's true.  Questions are left unanswered, loose ends aren't tied up properly, and the reader is left wondering, "What the hell?".

So why on earth are we telling you to read a book whose ending stinks?  Because the rest of the book simply excels above all other thrillers on the market.  This book, believe it or not, is worth reading despite the ending, pure and simple.




The Likeness is French's follow-up novel, and it takes the interesting twist of picking up Rob and Cassie's story where In the Woods left off, only this time from Cassie's point of view.  A new case pops up and this time, it's Cassie who must deal with demons from her past as she goes deep undercover at a local University.

With this novel you can literally see for yourself French's honing of her craft.  Her strengths (again, characterization and dialog) become stronger and her weakness (plot) improves dramatically.  She deftly weaves an intricate mystery that, once again, keeps the reader glued to the pages and this time she doesn't make the same mistake with the ending.

This book, of the two, will not leave you disappointed in the ending.  And yet A Reader's Respite cannot, in good conscious, recommend that you read only this second novel as a stand alone.  You must read the both of them in order to experience the joy of seeing a talented writer mature and progress until the end result is almost magical.

If you appreciate the craft of writing and enjoy seeing a master of it at work, do yourself a favor and pick up both of these novels.  It really is a thing of beauty.






FTC Disclaimer:

Hey Mr. FTC-Man....cash out of pocket, baby, cash out of pocket.  Put that in your pipe and smoke it.

Adventures in Reading....

Last week, A Reader's Respite decided that it was time to dive into the Take Another Chance Challenge, sponsored by Find Your Next Book Here (Jenners is gonna be so proud of us!).




The first thing we had to do was to use a randomizer to pick a blog from our blogroll.  This sounded like fun until the first four blogs that came up for me were NO LONGER IN SERVICE.  What the hell is up with that, people?  You just abandon us in our time of need?  (Not to mention what that says about A Reader's Respite's laziness with updating our blogroll....sheesh, maybe we need to participate in the next Bloggiesta?)

The fifth roll of the randomizer thankfully took us to Beth Fish Reads, who does us the favor of not just quitting the book review business without letting us know.  And what did we find at Beth Fish Reads?  An intriguing short review of a book by Nancy Pickard, entitled The Virgin of Small Plains.




One trip to the bookstore later and we had our hot little hands on a copy.  And once we started reading, A Reader's Respite couldn't put the darned thing down.

We'd like to categorize this compelling novel as a Literary Mystery (is there such a genre?  If not, there is now...).  You see, some 30 years ago, the body of a young woman was found during a blizzard in the rural community of Small Plains, Kansas.  Who was she?  Who killed her?  And why did her mysterious death shatter so many lives?

Told in alternating past and present chapters, The Virgin of Small Plains is both deliberate and thoughtful, beautifully written with just enough tension to keep the reader embroiled in the story.  It was, for us, the perfect blend of characterization and plot: any more characterization and the novel would have been too boring, any more plot and it would have been a mediocre thriller.

Published in 2006, this novel is readily available in paperback and we found it easily in a used bookstore.  Or, you could enter to win our gently-read copy.  Just leave a comment and we'll draw a random winner on February 15th!



Dear FTC,

We hope you all are actually taking the time to read our disclosures.  We go to a lot of trouble just to make sure the world knows that we purchased this book.  Mr. RR especially loves keeping track of how many books we are buying so he has a valid reason to bitch at us whilst he balances the checkbook.

Sincerely,

A Reader's Respite

A New Cozy Mystery Series



There's a new cozy mystery series in town, an event that always makes A Reader's Respite smile.  Cozy mysteries always seem to be the perfect read in these dreary winter months.  Stuck in bed with the flu?  A cozy mystery fits the bill nicely....short reads, nothing too deep or philosophical to tax a Sudafed-laden brain.

The new Daphne Martin Mystery series by author Gayle Trent is a particular treat (pun intended) for those readers who also love to bake.  Wholesome (nary a bedroom scene to be found) and light-hearted, these short mysteries eschew deep character analysis, instead focusing on a protagonist we can relate.

Daphne Martin, a newly divorced cake decorator who has moved back to her home town of Brea Ridge, Virginia to start life over close to her family, stumbling inadvertently into local mysteries and baking up a storm amid a cast of fun, eccentric secondary characters.

The mysteries aren't too convoluted, but neither are they simplistic.  Daphne's baking techniques are detailed throughout which, if you enjoy cake baking and decorating, is a fun little addition.  If baking cakes isn't your cup of tea, beware that these details might prove a tad distracting to the story.  As a bonus, the recipes Daphne uses throughout each story are served up at the end of the book - a delightful addition!


A Reader's Respite wishes we were this talented....alas, not likely to happen

There's really no need to read these in order (and given A Reader's Respite's infamous Series OCD, that's an astounding statement, but it's true, we assure you).  The author does a fine job in the second novel, Dead Pan, of bringing the reader up-to-date without making you feel like you are missing something very important, which is no mean feat in the world of serial novels.

So if you are looking for a cozy mystery that doesn't take literature too seriously, keep an eye out for Gayle Trent.  Her books are a small pleasure, perfect to read in between your Hemingway and Dickens.


FTC, USDA, DoD, TSA, Whatever Disclosure:

The first book in Gayle Trent's Daphne Martin Cake Decorating Series, Murder Takes the Cake, zapped it's way to our Amazonian Devil Device (ie, Kindle) via a mess of convoluted radio waves.  Call it technological trickery if you will.  It didn't cost us a red cent because Amazon was offering the download for free that day.  We weren't cheap, just lucky.

The second book of the series, Dead Pan, winged it's way to our doorstep in the form of a bound galley for review from the author.  This didn't cost us a red cent, either.  Get over it.

*****

Murder Takes the Cake was published in Fall 2008, so it is readily available in paperback.  Strangely, a couple of weeks ago, Amazon was also offering the book via Kindle for a free download, but now it seems to have disappeared from Amazon's Kindle Store entirely.  *Sigh*  Another Amazonian mystery (maybe Gayle Trent should tackle that mystery for her next book).

Dead Pan was released this past October in paperback and is also currently available for Kindle download.

*****

If anyone's interested in a galley of the Dead Pan, the second book in the series, leave a comment here.  We'll draw a random winner on January 30th and mail you our review copy!

Mysterious goings-on

headless and in black and white? they're bringing forth the big guns here.

November seems to us to be a good month for reading mysteries. Or maybe it's just a good month to read A Duty to the Dead, the debut novel in Charles Todd's new mystery series.

For the most part, we really enjoyed this novel. Set in England in 1916, the World War I setting appealed to our historical bent and Todd's new heroine, Bess Crawford, is truly the perfect protagonist: independent without being pushy, brave without being a hero.

A nurse home on medical leave in World War I England, Bess sets out to find the family of a dead soldier who entrusted her with delivering them a final cryptic message on his death bed.

Upon arrival at the family's estate, Bess finds herself embroiled in a dangerous mystery involving family secrets, lies and treachery.

What we liked about Bess were her motivations. Many mysteries come up with stock, boring reasons to keep the protagonist hanging around to sort things out, but Todd is original and remains true to the characters throughout.

We did find the dialogue becoming a bit tangled towards the end, as the characters themselves discussed every possible (and some not-so-possible) solutions to the mystery at hand, which we assume was a tactic aimed at keeping the reader guessing, although it merely gave us a slight headache.

But we simply popped a couple of Tylenol and pushed on, given that we were vested in the fate of stoic, charming Bess.

hey, whatever it takes, right?

For those of you who aren't familiar with this bestselling author, Charles Todd is actually two people: a mother and son writing team, Caroline and Charles Todd.

How cool is that?

A Reader's Respite would be thrilled if we could just teach our son to write his name so he could get his butt into preschool, let alone write a novel with us. Sheesh.






Of course we're offering this one up...who loves ya baby? This is a great chance to read a great mystery and get in on the start of what is to be a whole new series. Just leave us a comment if you're interested (international entrants always welcome) and check back here on November 18th to see if you won.

It's that easy.

Cutesy, Cozy Mystery Alert!


Okay all of you cozy mystery lovers out there....new series alert! Bundle of Trouble is the first book of the new Maternal Instincts Mysteries by author Diana Orgain and mothers everywhere can rejoice.

New mother Kate Connolly has just given birth to her first child when she inadvertently finds herself embroiled in the mystery of her brother-in-law's disappearance. When the private investigator working the case winds up in the hospital, Kate finds herself solving not only the mystery of her brother-in-law, but possibly the mystery of how to avoid returning to her 9-5 office job at the end of her maternity leave.

Diana Orgain does a crack job of creating a plausible whodunit with a delightful protagonist. No deep, dark undercurrents in this new series and we're fairly certain that's just the way Ms. Orgain intended it. Upbeat and light-hearted (even, some might say, a bit saccharine at times), Kate Connolly's new mommy status brings back fond memories of those first hectic weeks with an infant.

Mother's everywhere who like a cozy mystery now and again will most certainly enjoy this fun, quick read. Ms. Orgain delivers! (Bad, bad pun. Get over it.)

We like.

We especially like getting in on the beginning of a new series!





Do you want in on the first book of a new series? Leave us a comment and on September 1st, A Reader's Respite will draw a random winner to receive Bundle of Trouble!

Review: Her Royal Spyness

Her Royal Spyness (Solves Her First Case), by Rhys Bowen




Is it just A Reader's Respite or is anyone else out there unreasonably attracted to cute book covers?

Most times our predilection for buying books based on cute covers comes back to bite us in the ass, but every once in a while we turn the last page feeling enormously pleased with ourselves.

This is one of those times.

Award-winning author Rhys Bowen - of Molly Murphy and Constable Evans fame - has hit a homerun with her newest mystery series, A Royal Spyness. Meet Lady Victoria Georgiana Charlotte Eugenie. She is thirty-fourth in line for the throne of England, dead broke, and she will be the first to tell you that is not a desirable place to be, especially for a single gal in 1930s London.

But Georgie, as she's pragmatically shortened her name to, is nothing if not practical. She's blazing her own path by setting up her own housekeeping service (in disguise, of course), finding love with a completely unsuitable man, of course, spying on Wallis Simpson for the Queen, and solving the mystery of a dead man who turned up in her bathtub.

What follows is a lighthearted romp with minor royalty and the usual suspects lurking around every corner. It's simply delightful.

Don't expect a convoluted plot here, folks. This is simply a fun little mystery that's less about the mystery and more about the fun, eccentric characters.




Title: Her Royal Spyness
Author: Rhys Bowen
ISBN-13: 978-0425215678
324 pages
Publisher: Berkeley
Date: July 2008 (pbk)

Other peeps who've read it:

Reactions to Reading
Mysteries in Paradise
A Library Girl's Familiar Diversions
Nancy J. Cohen's Notes from Florida
Matt Fatal (en espanol)
Writing well is the best revenge
Mixed Book Bag
A library is a hospital for the mind...
and that's my Egypt!
What a Tragic Comedy
One Girl and Her Books
Scaling Mt. TBR

Review: Blood Island


Blood Island: A Matt Royal Mystery, by H. Terrell Griffin




The Quick Synopsis
Retired attorney Matt Royal is enjoying his retirement down in Florida when he gets a call from his ex-wife who asks for his help locating her missing step-daughter. All of a sudden, dead bodies are popping up everywhere and Matt is right in the middle of it. Drug dealers, the mob, religious cults - you name it and this mystery has it.


There's a darkness lurking deep in the souls of us all. Our parents instill in us a modicum of civilized behavior and that usually keeps our baser instincts at bay. But sometimes that blackness seeps to the surface and a monster walks quietly among us.
Blood Island, by H. Terrell Griffin

The Literary Criticism
Griffin has a talent for writing the grand noir mystery tradition. Think Sam Spade meets Miami Vice.

(Humphrey Bogart as Sam Spade, for those of you too young to get my references)

The tight plot is fast paced from the very first chapter and reels you in hook, line, and sinker. Short chapters keep the plot moving right along and Griffin doesn't drop his end-of-the-chapter teasers just because it's the middle of the story.

Particularly impressive is the author's ability to convey all of the darkness of Florida's underworld without overdosing on explicitness. Sex is implied rather than detailed, the language is appropriate for the scene, and violence...well, we are talking about drug dealers and the mob here, after all.
People who lurk on the edges of civilization know that their greatest protection from the wrath of society is the unwillingness of good people to do bad things.
Sometimes, the lurkers misjudge.
Blood Island, by H. Terrell Griffin

There were a few stumbles here and there, such as a goodly number of characters introduced in a very short time span, but nothing that detracts from the story overall. And while the ending is looser than I would have liked, Griffin's just plain good writing more than makes up for any small complaints I had.

And evidently I'm not the only one smitten with Griffin's work. Blood Island was a finalist in the National Best Books 2008 Awards. I'm not surprised one bit.


The Recommendation
I loved, loved this book and would highly recommend it for any fan of a good mystery. Looking for a holiday gift for the manly-man in your life? This book is it (and then steal it for yourself to enjoy!) And if you love it as much as I did, keep in mind that Blood Island is the third in the Matt Royal Series. I can't wait to read the other two books in the series, Murder Key and Longboat Blues.



(The man who makes the magic happen: H. Terrell Griffin)


Win a Copy!
H. Terrell Griffin is giving away a signed copy of his book, Blood Island , to one lucky tour visitor. Go to Terry’s book tour page and enter your name, e-mail address, and this PIN, 3838, for your chance to win. Entries from A Reader's Respite will be accepted until 12:00 Noon (PT) tomorrow. No purchase is required to enter or to win. The winner (first name only) will be announced on Terry’s book tour page next week.

Four and a half stars!



Title: Blood Island: A Matt Royal Mystery
Author: H. Terrell Griffin
ISBN-13: 978-1933515212
234 pages
Publisher: Oceanview Publishing
Date: December 2008


Other Reviews in Blogland:

Jenn's Bookshelf